top of page

Is an evaluator who does not believe parental alienation is part of the dsm-5 but takes on a family ordered to do an evaluation with an alienation component violating their code of ethics?

Whether an evaluator is violating their code of ethics by taking on a custodial evaluation with a parental alienation component depends on the specific ethical guidelines and standards set forth by their professional organization or licensing board. In general, evaluators are expected to adhere to ethical principles such as objectivity, integrity, competence, and avoidance of conflicts of interest.

Here are some key considerations related to this scenario:

1. Competence: Evaluators should only accept cases and evaluations that fall within their area of expertise and competence. If an evaluator lacks the necessary knowledge and training to properly assess parental alienation dynamics, they may be violating ethical guidelines by taking on such a case.

2. Impartiality: Evaluators must maintain impartiality and objectivity throughout the evaluation process. If there are concerns about bias or conflicts of interest that may impact the evaluator's ability to provide an unbiased assessment, it could raise ethical issues.

3. Informed Consent: It is essential for the evaluator to ensure that all parties involved in the evaluation understand the scope of the assessment, including any focus on parental alienation, and provide informed consent. Failure to communicate the nature of the evaluation effectively can lead to ethical concerns.

4. Conflict of Interest: If the evaluator has a personal or professional relationship with one of the parties involved in the evaluation that may compromise their ability to remain impartial, it could raise ethical red flags.

Before accepting a custodial evaluation with a parental alienation component, the evaluator should carefully consider whether they have the necessary expertise, ability to remain unbiased, and potential conflicts of interest that may arise. Seeking guidance from their professional organization or ethical committee can help clarify any uncertainty regarding ethical responsibilities in this context.



bottom of page